The Maritime Blog: Solving the Mantoloking Beach Ship Mystery

Do you remember when the decking of an old wooden ship was dug up on the beach in Mantoloking last Brick Mystery for blogNovember? Every newspaper and every local TV news station had a reporter “on the scene” accepting any and all guesses over which ship it might be. Then all went silent. Without new information, the mystery ship disappeared from almost everyone’s radar. We at the New Jersey Maritime Museum still care and we continue to follow the activities of the NJ Dept of Environmental Protection in their search for an identity.

The ship was uncovered while building a 3.5 mile retaining wall on the Mantoloking Beach as part of the recovery efforts from Storm Sandy. Construction was halted at that spot but continued elsewhere. An archeologist and historian were hired by the DEP to investigate the wreck. Unfortunately, several important planks were illicitly removed from the site. What still existed of the excavated wreckage was moved to an undisclosed NJ State garage, an adjusted path was designed for the retaining wall and the construction work was completed. The rest of the ship still lies 25 feet under the dune.

The archaeologist is now working with the deck material that he has. He (and we) are searching for every bit of information from 19th century news clippings, US Lifesaving Service reports and marine intelligence reports to determine the ultimate fate of ships that went ashore in the immediate area of our mystery ship. Our museum records can identify about 30 strandings that occurred between 1837 to 1880 within a 2.5 mile stretch of beach. Research has found that several of those stranded ships were re-floated and towed away.

Further, the archaeologist believes the ship was in excess of 100 feet in length and trans-Atlantic passage capable. That eliminates many coastwise vessels including small schooners, sloops, fishing boats and barges.

We continue to keep in touch with the archaeologist and our friends in the DEP Historic Preservation office.

My hope (my dream?) is that funding will be found to dig up the rest of the buried remains which will certainly provide a clue to its identity. I personally have narrowed down the possibilities to five or six ships and have picked out two most-likely favorites. What are they?

Stay tuned.

Blog contribution by Dave Swope


Related Posts
Showing 3 comments
  • Jonathan Stokes

    Hey Dave. That’s fascinating! Did the funding come through for the remains? Eager to read about the 5-6 ships you mentioned. Couldn’t find the follow-up post though.

  • James McLaughlin

    I would love to know.Were any other artifacts found?

  • John Kline

    HI , I am looking for any information that anyone may have about a shipwreck that was uncovered several years ago during a dredging project at Corson Inlet . I heard that the dredge was pumping sand back onto Strathmere beach and a lot of old coins were pumped onto the beach ,
    many 8 reales and other coins were found by several people using metal detectors. I also heard that someone ( a government agency ) told
    Great Lakes Dredge and Dock to put a smaller screen at the end of the pump to catch more artifacts , and that no one could search the beach.
    I am wondering if anyone knows what shipwreck this was ? Please feel free to contact me by e-mail or call me at 215-791-4850.
    Thank you ,
    John Kline

Leave a Comment